Public sentiment towards the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls is predominantly negative, with widespread concerns about potential voter disenfranchisement and the perceived political motivations behind the initiative. Many commenters express distrust in the government's intentions and the electoral commission's capability to conduct the revision fairly and transparently. Calls for more structured processes and greater accountability are prevalent among users, reflecting frustration with the current political climate.

Election Commission of India

y'all care too much about pressing the "does-nothing" button once in five years.

ManMarkedByFlames

Edit:

&gt; Reports indicate that women have been left of out of the draft voter list in larger numbers. It will also impact millions of migrant workers who migrate out of Bihar. A survey revealed that 90% of the migrant workers had not even heard about the exercise, and more than a third had none of the documents required by the ECI.

These lines must be added at the end of the penultimate paragraph.

rishianand

Who cares? Congress and BJP are two sides of the same capitalist coin. Whether it’s Congress’s past scams or BJP’s current voter roll manipulations, the result is the same democracy hollowed out.

inquisitive_tej

Repost by changing the title to reflect the title used in the source because this post will be removed.

Professional-Tear996

1935 e Nazi Germany Nuremberg e German Jews der voting rights kharij kore.

Itihash theke sekha ucchit

barmanrags

The problem with such scurtiniees is that bureaucratic inefficiencies &amp; corruption will get in the way. A lot of "illegals" now hold immense power, political mileage and money, especially in West Bengal. 

A little bit of violence and/or money - and the scrutinizers may as well pass off legal citizens as scapegoats! Parts of Bengal have indigenous Muslim population which has below average income, whereas a lot of these Bangladeshis have garnered not just money but muscle &amp; political power as well.

So that begs the question, will it be as transparent as it's being positioned as?

Sudden-Celebration14

Will there be a domicile check? How will they identify legal and illegal immigrants? Also what are the rules for Indian citizens to transfer their voter card to a constituency?

mukherjee4u

BJP have successfully created the propaganda against bengali for apparently hiding Bangladeshis for votes which is obviously a lie for this. Now they will start removing most Bengalis who votes against them.

MysteriousFox6947

State sponsored ethnic clea\*sing of bengalis in action (I have been screaming about it for over a year now as all the tell-tale signs were evident which I have been documenting). Propaganda of dehumanisation of bengalis, has been running long in this nation.  Mass ex\*cutions in detention camps will begin soon. Buckle up and save your motherland. If Supreme court doesn't strike this down, get ready for the final ride.

Afraid_Ask5130

[deleted]

Posted the same thing yesterday. It got removed. Lets hope this one sticks.

Relevant_Rhubarb_629

The real reason for this is to ensure demographic change in WB. This has been implemented in Bihar, and 8 crore voters were asked to submit form and 'documents'(which excludes Aadhar/ration card/voter card) within a month. Bihar has 33 percent of their existing population living outside Bihar. This will happen in WB as well.How is it possible for them to get leaves from their employers, travel back  and submit form and documents. And regarding the documents ECI asked for parents birth certificate..... even one of the judges who is hearing this case in SC quoted that he himself can't provide the documents asked by the ECI. 

The Chief Election Commisioner himself stated that he wants people to vote where they currently 'reside' not their native place. You can check that in that following link. So, all the Bihar voters who weren't able to go back can submit their documents at their 'current address' , so basically Bengal which holds a huge chunk of these people will now have the migrant Bihar population as a legitimate voter base. 

As someone who have been to Tibet, I can assure you this is exactly what China did in Tibet. In Tibet you would hardly find any Tibetans, but Han Chinese while actual Tibetans were given lucrative opportunities to move to different urban areas like Shanghai,  Beijing etc . The same is being tried in Xingjiang areas with Uyighurs.


The motive of the excercise is evident when you have Bihar which has one of the lowest migrant population within the state is chosen as the first state for this excercise. You can't sell the' illegal  Bangladeshi Muslim' thing there because the local people know the condition of the state and no sane people will move there unless it's an absolute necessity. 

They day government changed the panel of selection of ECI commissioners by removing the Chief Justice of India from the panel, replacing him/her with a MP from the ruling party the downfall of ECI began.



https://www.google.com/amp/s/m.economictimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/citizens-should-register-themselves-as-voters-only-in-constituencies-they-are-ordinary-residents-chief-election-commissioner/amp_articleshow/122184020.cms

65th_government

Good!

If we cant get NRC like Assam, I am willing to take this.


Every voter card issued after 2000 should be closely monitored.

Especially when a new card is being issued to a 30year old, with newly minted Aadhar

OkCustomer5021

Dayum that Bangladeshi Navy vessel is so majestic

Billa_Gaming_YT

Compared to the number illegals, this is miniscule though. I hope the govt. keeps pushing with the initiative and should continue till every kanglu is thrown out. There is also of chance of some of them coming back once things cool down. That would be a grave mistake the govt. could make. Things should never cool down.

Accomplished-Wolf796

Good. This must continue till the last infiltrator is pushed back..

RelevantBet1384

NewWheelView

I hope those kanglus leave Bengal and Bengali Hindus can make Bengal better with a better government and their voice may not be suppressed

Aggravating-Bell-335

Nice to see them leave with only backpack or handbags

dsouzaenoch

That's actually noble cause common man never wants blood .

Accha hai let them go

IcyLow9565

And what's to prevent them from re entering once SIR is done? Problem is widespread corruption that enables them to thrive here with secret blessings of all political parties and porous borders.

warhammer047

So hopefully after this, discussion about them will stop, right? And bsf will not allow them back in.

Omarr_Paper

BNS BOkaC\*oda on there way to recieve them

Accomplished-Film311

Now it make sense why the opposition is hell bent against SIR. And wants all documents to be included as a proof. 

We need an extensive Aadhar revision. One good step about Assam is, no Aadhar without Parents being an already Aadhar holder.

Epsilon009

Just the tip of the iceberg but still good news

Rambo_765

Timely_Virus_4015

Its ok to hate beggardeshis but to make fake videos of exodus is idiotic attempt by IT cells. . Why dont you make videos on politicians receiving mota pension , pothole ridden  roads, scamsters fleeing country, ????

Intrivort

missicipius

LawrenceCrew11

No-Corner-8537

chikorita_here

WoodenNothing8935

justhandyouknow

Boring-Locksmith-473

After continuing SIR for a few more weeks, the Govt should start Pradhanmantri infiltrator shoot at sight Yojna. That will solve a lot of things

swordrunner1

Are they going back temporarily?
They will come back again after elections

Inside_Ball_6993

Tough-Rooster-2003

Wait, it's that easy? What would happen after SIR? Will they come back?

theagentK1

Implement in entire India. Reinforce our borders well.

![gif](giphy|2sW1FDfiYtqbm|downsized)

ActiveDue6175

This should be done in every state especially The Northeast!

Weekly-Reindeer4888

There have been a lot of these videos floating- most are fake, of random crowds. i wish it was true.

Globalistacoolhead

BC itne illegal Bangladeshi the yaha 🤔

raipurstud

Ok. But by matushka rossia in the song ? 🤣🤣🤣

3l-d1abl0

Fit_Entertainment897

Asn_Krish

Ksb2311

EntertainmentOnly96

And they just clicks pics and allows them to go?

Cuck-Hub-India

We need this Manipur!! Hell we need this in the enitre Northeast!!!!!!

darktower41

They are not leaving anywhere,there just dispersing to Jharkhand and Bihar.
East Bihar is already a gone case.

panautiloser

bitter-bitter

Live_rooted

All will come back aftwr elections are over

dioraddict1983

Sea-Hat-5184

Is this authentic or just repurposing some of our AI videos?

404LogicNotFoundNow

That Kolkata sub was celebrating a few days ago as not many foreigners were found in the SIR in West Bengal.

prvnkdvd

 Unless bsf does their job they gonna come back.

angrydolphin69

Spreading random fake unverified news 😂 and see the dumb fanatics falling for it

Slight_Revolution793

So it means Bangladesh people can't live in india?

PANDAC0CO

ZG_forever

Hello, u/Guilty-King-9047! Thank you for your submission to r/CriticalThinkingIndia. We appreciate your contribution to our community.

- If your submission is a photo/video, please provide the source under this comment.
- If your submission is a link, please provide a summary of the information from that link in the comments.

We hope you'll follow our rules and engage in meaningful discussions.

*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CriticalThinkingIndia) if you have any questions or concerns.*

AutoModerator

People elect government by voting. The government has a separate body EC to conduct elections. Now EC has to create another body to audit the fairness of EC's own work. If there is no trust in the constitution then why even call ourselves a democracy.

SIR is as simple as a revision of existing voter's data. Any discrepancy will discard the voter card and if there is legitimacy than the voter can reclaim the cancelled voter id.

Just because you have a different political affiliation than in power, doesn't make sense of your baseless criticism of EC SIR with impractical solutions. Next you will say that we need auditors to audit auditors who audited SIR.

BlueAlpha29

You are simply criticizing EC SIR but unable to explain why SIR is an ineffective process.

1. You said that disqualified voters have to fill a enumeration form and this is unprecedented. So who should be filling if not the voter themself.

2.  You are saying that in SIR people have to prove their eligibility. If not people themself, then who should be providing document ?

You are expecting EC to provide a 5 star services or Governance ?

People keep forgetting. There have been 10+ SIRs that have already happened since the 1950s and it is not a new thing.

DearHippo9388


* Please provide a source to the image/video below the comment. If source is not provided then the post will be removed.

* Use the same title as that of the source link. Editorialised titles are not allowed

* If it is Original Content (video/pic taken by you) then please respond with OC below the comment

* If it's meme/satire, please use the meme/cartoon flair and provide the link to the original creator. Memes will be allowed as per mod discretion and can be removed without explanation.

*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/unitedstatesofindia) if you have any questions or concerns.*

Largest democracy on the planet, you have what is the most important constitutional body in a democracy doing fraudulent practices in broad daylight. 

Yet there is no visibility of this in national television anything to the level that is required, even little from international media. 

We are doomed and on our own. I hate the feeling of surendering to my own forebodings that we could never wake out of this nasty fever dream of fascism unfolding itself violently all around us. 
Rahul please do something 

Also thanks for your post, very illuminating!

VegetableRutabaga746

Congress has problems if there are duplicate voters and emigrated voters is the list in karnataka. They also have problems if such voters are removed in bihar too. They just want to use lies so as to capture power, they want bangladeshis and rohingyas to vote

Critifin

The Supreme Court is reviewing petitions regarding the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, sparking discussions on voter disenfranchisement.

Special Intensive Revision of Electoral Rolls in India

Why This Matters

Public Sentiment Summary

Highlighted Comments

Parties Involved

What the people want